XTB Shares Fall for Second Day as Profit Slump Hits Investors Sentiment
XTB shares
fell for a second consecutive session today (Monday), sliding to an intraday
low of 86.40 PLN before recovering to around 89.22 PLN, a decline of roughly
2.5% on the day. The pullback, which stretches over two trading sessions, has
taken the Warsaw-listed broker (WSE: XTB) to its lowest level
since February 24, and represents a roughly 9% retreat from the stock's
all-time high of 96.94 PLN reached just two weeks ago on March 10.Singapore Summit: Meet the largest APAC brokers you know (and those you still don't!)The
pressure dates back to March 19, when XTB published its consolidated
annual report for 2025, showing record revenues that masked a sharp deterioration in
profitability. Trading the following day opened with heavy selling, with shares
dropping from around 94.98 PLN to an intraday low of 90.10 PLN before closing
at 91.58 PLN, the steepest single-session decline the stock had seen since
November 2025.XTB’s Record Revenue,
Shrinking ProfitsThe numbers
at the top of the income statement were unambiguously strong. Total operating
income rose 14.6% year-over-year to PLN 2.15 billion in 2025, a company record,
according to the annual report.But operating costs rose nearly three times
faster, up 48.2% to PLN 1.31 billion, leaving net profit at PLN 644.2 million,
down 24.8% from PLN 856.9 million in 2024. Earnings per share fell from PLN
7.29 to PLN 5.48 over the same period.The single
largest driver of the cost increase was marketing. XTB's marketing bill rose
69.6% to PLN 584.9 million in 2025, including PLN 405 million in online
spending alone, up from PLN 262.3 million a year earlier. Staff costs followed,
rising 32.6% to PLN 413 million, while IT and licensing expenses nearly doubled
to PLN 73 million from PLN 39.4 million. The net profit margin contracted from
roughly 46% in 2024 to around 30% in 2025, a shift investors are struggling to
look past.Two further
line items stand out from the report. Financial costs surged from PLN 1.1
million in 2024 to PLN 94.6 million in 2025, driven almost entirely by foreign
exchange losses of PLN 93.1 million, primarily the result of PLN strengthening
against the dollar and euro. Revenue per active client also fell 32.5%, from
PLN 2.7 thousand to PLN 1.8 thousand, a metric that reflects the dilutive
effect of bringing in large volumes of lower-activity accounts.The Cost Guidance That
Unnerved MarketsIf the 2025 numbers were the catalyst, it is the company's own forward-looking commentary in the annual report that has kept sellers engaged. The management board states directly in the report: "In 2026, total operating costs may be up to approximately 30% higher compared to what we observed in 2025. The Management Board's priority is the continued growth of the client base and building a global brand. As a result, marketing expenditures may increase by approximately 50% compared to the previous year," according to the 2025 annual report. The company adds that in the medium term, meaning the 2027 to 2029 horizon, marketing costs could grow 30% to 40% annually, with the assumption that the average cost of client acquisition remains broadly in line with the 2023 to 2026 range.For
investors who had priced in both growth and margin recovery, that kind of
guidance leaves little room for optimism in the near term. The
firm had forecast full-year 2025 net profit of around PLN 673 million back in
January, a figure that ultimately proved reasonably close to the mark,
though the context of the cost trajectory heading into 2026 has shifted the
picture considerably.The Client BetCEO Omar
Arnaout has been consistent in framing client acquisition as the company's
defining priority, and the 2025 numbers bear that strategy out. XTB added
864,286 new clients during the year, a 73% jump from 498,438 in 2024, pushing
the total base past 2.16 million. In an interview
published in February,
Arnaout called reaching two million new clients annually "completely
realistic" within a few years, noting that "it took us 20 years to
have a million clients" and that "in 2025, we acquired over 860,000
clients."Moreover, asked in an April 2025 interview at XTB's Warsaw headquarters which KPIs matter more, revenue and profit or client acquisition, Arnaout did not hedge:"I
would be lying if I said profit wasn't important to us. But I'll be honest.
Even when we present slightly worse financial results to institutional
investors, if we see that our client acquisition was very high, clients are
actively using our application and are satisfied with it, and deposits were
strong with significant increases in trading volumes, personally, that's more
important to me than the financial results. It builds a base for a significant
increase in profits over time. The end goal will always be reaching the highest
level of profits."That view
is difficult to reconcile with the market's reaction, and the tension is a
familiar one for XTB investors. The company keeps delivering on client growth,
while the market keeps discounting the earnings that growth produces. The average
cost per new client acquisition was PLN 677 in 2025, broadly in line with prior
years, but that efficiency metric does not, on its own, resolve the question of
whether the aggressive spend is a temporary investment or a structural shift in
the cost base.Profitability
per lot, a key operating metric, also deteriorated, falling 21.8% to PLN 215
from PLN 275 in 2024. Volume grew sharply but at diminishing returns. On a
quarterly basis, Q4 2025 was the weakest period of the year, with net profit of
just PLN 160.3 million, compared to a peak of PLN 302.7 million in Q2.Africa Exit and
Institutional WeaknessThe annual
report also disclosed the
sale of XTB's South African subsidiary for $645,000 to an unnamed buyer, closing
out an eight-year attempt to enter the African continent that never generated a
single client transaction. The deal, signed on February 17, 2026, and still
pending FSCA regulatory approval, represents a minor write-off in financial
terms, but it underscores a pattern of geographic retreats outside XTB's
European core.Separately,
the company's institutional segment, operated under the X Open Hub brand, saw
revenues fall 48.3% year-over-year to PLN 42.5 million in 2025, a notable
reversal from the PLN 82.3 million generated in 2024. The segment, which
provides liquidity and trading technology to other financial institutions, is
known for revenue volatility, but the scale of the decline adds another layer
of nuance to what was otherwise a strong top-line year.Technicals Remain StrongFrom a
technical perspective, the picture remains within a broader consolidation
range. The stock has been trading between approximately 86 PLN, a support level
defined by the gap formed during the January and February rally, and
approximately 96 PLN, the vicinity of the all-time high.At 89.22
PLN, the shares sit closer to the lower end of that range than the upper, but
remain well above the early 2025 lows that preceded the strong rally now
partially reversing. XTB shares
have experienced sharp pullbacks before, including a 25% decline from peak to trough
in mid-2025, only to recover fully and push to new highs.Whether
this episode follows a similar path depends on whether investors conclude that
the company's aggressive spending is building lasting franchise value, or
eating into the very earnings that justified the stock's premium valuation in
the first place.
This article was written by Damian Chmiel at www.financemagnates.com.
Read More